THE STORY IN BRIEF
  • The scientists trained algorithms to approximate a process-based model of seabed sediments.
  • They estimate up to 11% of particulate organic carbon reaching the seafloor returns to the water in dissolved form.
  • Several simpler algorithms outperformed more complex alternatives for this particular modelling task.
MAKE TIME FOR A GOOD READ
Inside this story 2 perspectives

A particle of organic matter sinking through the sea is often treated as if it has reached its final destination when it lands on the bottom. For scientists trying to account for the world’s carbon, there is another stretch of the journey to follow. Material can break down in sediment, enter the water trapped between grains and move back into the ocean. Some of it can also attach to mineral surfaces and stay in the seabed.

A University of Manchester research account released on 8 September describes an attempt to estimate those movements across the globe. The underlying study, available online since March in The Innovation, uses a faster approximation of a detailed physical and chemical model. That allows the team to investigate places where repeating the original calculations at fine resolution would be too expensive in computing time.

Teaching a model to imitate a model

The researchers began with a numerical description of the processes occurring in seabed sediment. They trained competing algorithms to reproduce how that model responded under different conditions. The shortcut is called an emulator. It learns a relationship generated by a process-based calculation, rather than attempting to infer the entire chemistry of the seabed from a collection of unrelated photographs or measurements.

One result surprised the team. More elaborate machine-learning designs did not necessarily reproduce the original more faithfully. Relatively simple algorithms performed better in their tests. The researchers checked outputs against lower-resolution global calculations where the original model could still be run, and against mathematical solutions available for some quantities.

Where the carbon goes

The authors estimate that up to 11 per cent of the particulate organic carbon arriving on the global seafloor returns to seawater as dissolved organic carbon after breakdown within the sediment. In a separate calculation, they estimate that around half the solid organic carbon in the top metre of sediment originated through the attachment of dissolved material to minerals. The figures describe different things. One concerns the fate of incoming material, the other the origin of a stock already present in the sediment.

The model also highlights the vast flat regions of deep ocean floor beyond the continental margins. A process that proceeds relatively slowly per square metre can still add up across a very large area. Leaving the deepest regions out because they are harder to sample could therefore distort the overall accounting.

These are model-based estimates. They can help scientists decide where new observations would be especially informative and where a global simulation may be missing an important exchange. They do not make the seabed a simple storage account. A useful carbon budget needs to follow the material that comes back as carefully as it counts the material going down.

BB
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Beyond Business Editors

Editorial desk

Beyond Business connects global developments with the decisions, ambitions and everyday lives of its readers. Our editorial desk explores the stories shaping our world.

More from this author
Keep the perspective.