THE STORY IN BRIEF
  • TAMWILCOM said the programme supported nearly 1,000 entrepreneurs and financed more than 500 startups.
  • It reported more than 590 million dirhams mobilised through grants, loans and investments.
  • Four seed and venture funds established with programme support invested over 500 million dirhams in about 40 companies.
MAKE TIME FOR A GOOD READ
Inside this story 2 perspectives

The figures Morocco presented in Rabat on 17 September look, at first, like the stages in a familiar competition. Nearly 1,000 entrepreneurs received support through Innov Invest, more than 500 startups received finance, and about 40 companies attracted investment from four seed and venture funds established with programme support. But those figures cannot be lined up to determine the chance of an individual entrepreneur making it to the last round. They count different things.

TAMWILCOM, the public institution implementing Innov Invest for Morocco’s finance ministry, was reporting on a programme launched in 2017 with World Bank support. It said the programme had mobilised more than 590 million dirhams through grants, loans and investments. The four funds had invested over 500 million dirhams in around 40 startups. The announcement presents two ways that finance reached businesses. Adding the totals without checking how flows between the programme and the funds are recorded could count some of the same money twice.

Who holds the risk?

Each of the three forms of finance changes a young company's position differently. A grant can cover an early experiment that would be difficult to fund with debt. A loan means the company has a repayment obligation. A share investment puts an investor alongside the founders as an owner, with the terms determining how a later sale or financing is shared. “Funded” is meaningful, but it can describe three quite different next mornings for a business.

Creating a fund introduces another decision-maker. Public money can help establish an investment vehicle while its managers decide which companies to back and when to invest again. The World Bank's project documents explicitly identify the availability of private equity and related financing for innovative startups and small businesses as an objective. A founder may benefit from a longer-lasting investment industry as well as from a particular cheque.

What can be counted now

The Rabat review also reported more than 40 patents filed as part of supported projects. A filing records an effort to protect an invention. Converting it into a product customers repeatedly pay for requires other work. Similarly, one company can have several founders, and one founder can participate in more than one activity. A count of people receiving support is useful on its own terms without serving as the denominator of a startup success rate.

The most revealing follow-up would track what happened to particular groups of businesses over time. Which early grants led to outside investment? Which companies had enough revenue to service a loan? When a fund invested for a second time, what earlier uncertainty had the company resolved? Those questions build on the totals the programme can already report and get closer to the decisions that determine how an idea becomes a lasting business.

BB
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Beyond Business Editors

Editorial desk

Beyond Business connects global developments with the decisions, ambitions and everyday lives of its readers. Our editorial desk explores the stories shaping our world.

More from this author
Keep the perspective.