THE STORY IN BRIEF
  • The tax year resets in March, giving eligible members three possible windows since the September 2024 start.
  • Discovery reported that around 55% of eligible members in its analysis had never withdrawn.
  • SARS treats a savings withdrawal as taxable at the member’s marginal rate.
MAKE TIME FOR A GOOD READ
Inside this story 1 perspectives

The two-pot retirement system turns two on 1 September. By this anniversary, a South African member who was eligible throughout could already have made a savings withdrawal in three different tax years. The first opportunity opened in September 2024. March 2025 and March 2026 each opened another window. The calendar helps explain how frequently some people have returned to their fund, and why people who have never claimed remain a larger group than many might imagine.

Writing in Pensions World on 26 August, Discovery's Guy Chennells said around 55% of eligible members in its analysis had never accessed their savings pot. Approximately 27% had done so in more than one tax year. These are observations about the members in that analysis. They do not describe every fund in South Africa or measure how much each household needed the money.

An interview with financial planner Warren Ingram on EWN that same week illustrates how much the choice of denominator matters. Ingram said administrator figures suggested around two-thirds of people who withdrew in the first year had drawn again in the second. His starting group comprised people who had already withdrawn. Discovery's figures included eligible people who had never applied. Both observations can be true at once.

What counts as a new withdrawal year

National Treasury set 1 September 2024 as the commencement date. Under the new contribution split, one-third generally goes into the savings component and two-thirds into the retirement component. The latter stays invested for retirement. The rules also recognise a vested component for earlier savings, with applicable protections. The word “two” in everyday conversation describes the new split and can obscure that line on an older member's statement.

The South African Revenue Service says members can claim from the savings component once per tax year, generally with a minimum withdrawal of R2,000 and up to the amount available. The September anniversary does not create an extra opportunity in the tax year that began in March. A displayed balance and the right to make another claim are therefore separate questions.

The amount on the statement also differs from what may arrive in the bank. SARS uses the member's marginal income tax rate when calculating tax on a savings withdrawal benefit and requires a tax reference number. Retirement lump-sum tax tables are a different calculation. A member comparing the balance with a bill that needs paying would want to know the net proceeds before making that comparison.

The original reform gives a household a way to meet a present need while preserving part of its contributions for later. Its anniversary figures describe two distinct experiences. Some people have left every available rand invested. Others have made repeated use of the window. A percentage only begins to explain the human outcome when the fund identifies which group of savers it counted.

BB
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Beyond Business Editors

Editorial desk

Beyond Business connects global developments with the decisions, ambitions and everyday lives of its readers. Our editorial desk explores the stories shaping our world.

More from this author
Keep the perspective.